ARTICLE: On Using The Nelson-Denny Test for ESL Students at X College This essay explains why a reading test for American students won't work for non-American students and then shows the limitations of even a good test, such as the TOEFL. On Using The Nelson-Denny Test for ESL Students at X College NOTE: Since I criticized Dr. Ivy's position in this paper, it may seem that I had a poor regard for his teaching abilities, especially with ESL students. That is not true at all; Dr. Ivy was very effective as a teacher and with those students. I have substituted "X," "here," or "this school" for the name of the college where this happened throughout. T he issue being considered is as follows: The East-West Japanese students have taken several reading tests and have scored far below the American standard even after being allowed double time. Ellis Ivey, who has been teaching reading to them, feels that the reading class has been taught in the past to the ESL students with no standard. He suggests that we accept a score of 17.69 on the Nelson-Denny as a passing score since that is the average score earned by the ESL students this year at this school on the higher of their two Nelson-Denny tests (American students must earn 48.3). B efore giving my reply, I would like to explain my background. I am not trained as a reading teacher, but I did teach reading for one year in Kentucky and also for half a quarter to ESL students at the University of Alabama. Furthermore, I earned my second MA degree in TESL. My studies in English as a Second Language included a look at tests and testing. More broadly, we looked at theory and practice in the various areas of language learning and teaching, including reading. | |
|